Judiciary Act of 1789

GENERAL INFO

LONG TITLE

An Act to establish the Judicial Courts of the United States

ENACTED BY

The 1st Congress

SIGNED INTO LAW BY

George Washington

LEGISLATIVE HISTORY

INTRODUCED ON

June 12, 1789

INTRODUCED BY

Sen. Richard Henry Lee (VA)

SENATE VOTE

14 - 6; July 17, 1789

HOUSE VOTE

14 - 6; September 17, 1789

The Judiciary Act of 1789 | Credit: The National Archives

Legislative History

Congress began its first session on April 7, 1789. On the second day of its first session, the Senate passed a resolution to establish a Special Judiciary committee tasked with drafting legislation to create and organize the federal court system. Members of the committee included: Oliver Ellsworth (CT), Richard Bassett (DE), William Few (GA), Charles Carroll (MD), Caleb Strong (MA), William Paterson (NJ), Paine Wingate (NH), William Maclay (PA), Richard Izard (SC), and Richard Henry Lee (VA).

The Act was written primarily by Ellsworth and Paterson, both of whom would later serve on the Court. Original working drafts show that Paterson wrote the first nine sections, which established the circuit and district courts, and that Ellsworth wrote sections 10 through 23, which defined the jurisdiction and authority of the courts. Strong is credited with drafting the section regarding the rules of evidence and oral testimony in federal courts. Ellsworth’s work on the Act earned him the nickname “The Father of the Federal Judiciary.” After two months of drafting, Lee introduced the bill to the Senate as Senate Bill 1 on June 12, 1789. While Lee introduced the bill as the committee’s representative, he later tried to amend it to limit federal jurisdiction and ultimately voted against its final passage. The Senate debated the bill for 18 days and voted 14-6 to pass it.

On September 17, 1789, the House passed the bill with some amendments by a vote of 37-16. The House’s amendments limited appellate review to “issues of law”; mandated the use of state law except where federal law or treaties required otherwise; increased the monetary threshold for diversity cases; expanded the quorum for district courts; and refined how U.S. Marshals and deputies conducted service of process. The House’s passage of the bill was closely tied to the debate over the Bill of Rights, which were being finalized on the same day the House voted for the bill.

Overview

The Act constructed the federal judiciary as a three-tiered hierarchy consisting of a Supreme Court, three Circuit Courts, and 13 Judicial Districts.

The Supreme Court

The size of the Supreme Court was set at six justices, consisting of one Chief Justice and five Associate Justices. A quorum of four was required to conduct business, and the Court was mandated to hold two annual sessions in February and August at the seat of government.

The Act granted the Court exclusive original jurisdiction over civil actions between states, between a state and the U.S., and proceedings against diplomats. It also granted the Court non-exclusive original jurisdiction over other cases where a state was a party or an ambassador brought the suit. The Court was given appellate jurisdiction over decisions from federal circuit courts and state court rulings that invalidated federal statutes or treaties or upheld state laws challenged as unconstitutional. The Act also created the ability for a defendant sued in a plaintiff’s home state to remove the lawsuit to a federal circuit court.

Map of the District Courts and Circuit Courts created by the Judiciary Act of 1789 and Congress’ two subsequent Acts to include North Carolina and Rhode Island | Created With: mapchart.net

The District and Circuit Courts

There were 13 judicial districts created by the Act. These included Connecticut, Delaware, Georgia, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, and Virginia. Two special districts were created for Maine and Kentucky. The district courts had a single judge and primarily handled maritime and admiralty cases as well as minor federal crimes.

North Carolina was admitted to the Union on November 21, 1789, so Congress passed an June 4, 1790 to create the District of North Carolina under the Southern Circuit. After Rhode Island was admitted on May 20, 1790, Congress passed another extension on June 23, 1790, to create the District of Rhode Island under the Eastern Circuit. Shortly before Vermont was admitted as a state on March 4, 1971, Congress passed another extension on March 2 to create the District of Vermont, also under the Eastern Circuit.

The 13 districts were grouped into three larger geographic circuits: the Eastern, Middle, and Southern Circuits. These courts didn’t have their own judges and were instead composed of one local District Judge and two Supreme Court justices who “rode the circuit” to the districts to hear cases.

Cite this page